Uploaded image for project: 'Satellite'
  1. Satellite
  2. SAT-21268

Fetching Host's details does not scale wrt Hosts Collections

XMLWordPrintable

    • Sprint 131, Sprint 132, Sprint 133, Sprint 134, Sprint 135, Sprint 136, Sprint 137, Sprint 138, Sprint 139, Sprint 140, Sprint 141
    • Moderate
    • Yes

      Description of problem:
      Having many Host Collections with many Hosts associated to them, getting a Host details takes tens of seconds.

      E.g. having 5k Hosts and 100 Host Collections where five biggest Collections have 4k Hosts each, querying a Host (which is in all the five biggest Collections) takes tens of seconds.

      The more Host Collections (and the bigger they are) the Host is assigned to, the longer the query takes.

      Version-Release number of selected component (if applicable):
      Sat6.13

      How reproducible:
      100%

      Steps to Reproduce:
      1. Have thousands of Hosts (e.g. the 5k I had). You can populate your Satellite via a very few real Hosts, by repeatedly running on them something like:

      uuid=$(uuidgen)
      echo "{\"dmi.system.uuid\": \"${uuid}\"}" > /etc/rhsm/facts/uuid.facts
      hostnamectl set-hostname host-${uuid%%-*}.some.domain.com
      subscription-manager clean
      subscription-manager register --activationkey ak_test --org RedHat

      (each iteration of above commands creates one Host)

      2. Fetch a Host details few times, like:

      1. for i in $(seq 1 10); do time curl -ks -u admin:redhat 'https://localhost/api/v2/hosts/2520' > /dev/null; done 2>&1 | grep real
        real 0m0.269s
        real 0m0.258s
        real 0m0.255s
        real 0m0.253s
        real 0m0.252s
        real 0m0.266s
        real 0m0.667s
        real 0m0.255s
        real 0m0.246s
        real 0m0.256s
        #

      3. Create 100 Host Collections, empty so far:

      collections=100

      ( for i in $(seq 1 $collections); do
      echo "host-collection create --organization RedHat --name Host_Collection_${i} --unlimited-hosts"
      done ) | time hammer shell

      4. Fetch the Host repeatedly again, to ensure it is still same fast.
      5. Add many Hosts to the Host Collections, like e.g.:

      ( for c in $(seq 1 $collections); do
      hostids=$(su - postgres -c "psql foreman -c \"COPY (SELECT id FROM hosts WHERE id > $((10*c))) TO STDOUT\"" | tr '\n' ',' | sed "s/,$//g")
      echo "host-collection add-host --organization RedHat --name Host_Collection_${c} --host-ids ${hostids}"
      done ) | time hammer shell

      (each Host Collection will differ by 10 Hosts)

      6. Fetch the Host repeatedly again; optionally chose different Hosts depending on how many Host Collections they belong to (and how "big" Collections there are).

      E.g.:

      su - postgres -c "psql foreman -c \"SELECT COUNT,host_id FROM katello_host_collection_hosts GROUP BY host_id ORDER BY count DESC LIMIT 5;\""

      tells you Host IDs that are associated to the most Collections.

      Actual results:
      2. and 4. shows pretty ow times within one second.
      6. shows tens of seconds like:

      1. for i in $(seq 1 10); do time curl -ks -u admin:redhat 'https://localhost/api/v2/hosts/2520' > /dev/null; done 2>&1 | grep real
        real 0m24.980s
        real 0m35.901s
        real 0m26.356s
        real 0m23.446s
        real 0m26.306s
        real 0m26.919s
        real 0m36.831s
        real 1m10.623s
        real 0m35.503s
        real 0m19.224s
        #

      While a Host in just very few Host Collections is OK:

      1. for i in $(seq 1 10); do time curl -ks -u admin:redhat 'https://localhost/api/v2/hosts/51' > /dev/null; done 2>&1 | grep real
        real 0m4.446s
        real 0m1.202s
        real 0m1.704s
        real 0m0.978s
        real 0m1.007s
        real 0m1.190s
        real 0m1.831s
        real 0m0.907s
        real 0m1.049s
        real 0m2.015s
        #

      Expected results:
      All the times should be within a few seconds.

      Additional info:
      Enabling psql debugs, here is the source of slowness:

      2023-11-10T17:28:47 [I|app|c972f5f9] Started GET "/api/v2/hosts/2520" for 127.0.0.1 at 2023-11-10 17:28:47 +0100
      2023-11-10T17:28:47 [I|app|c972f5f9] Processing by Api::V2::HostsController#show as JSON
      2023-11-10T17:28:47 [I|app|c972f5f9] Parameters:

      {"apiv"=>"v2", "id"=>"2520"}

      ..
      2023-11-10T17:28:47 [D|sql|c972f5f9] Katello::HostCollection Load (0.6ms) SELECT "katello_host_collections".* FROM "katello_host_collections" INNER JOIN "katello_host_collection_hosts" ON "katello_host_collections"."id" = "katello_host_collection_hosts"."host_collection_id" WHERE "katello_host_collection_hosts"."host_id" = $1 [["host_id", 2520]]
      2023-11-10T17:28:47 [D|sql|c972f5f9] Host::Managed Load (14.7ms) SELECT "hosts".* FROM "hosts" INNER JOIN "katello_host_collection_hosts" ON "hosts"."id" = "katello_host_collection_hosts"."host_id" WHERE "hosts"."type" = $1 AND "katello_host_collection_hosts"."host_collection_id" = $2 [["type", "Host::Managed"], ["host_collection_id", 201]]
      2023-11-10T17:28:47 [D|sql|c972f5f9] Host::Managed Load (15.1ms) SELECT "hosts".* FROM "hosts" INNER JOIN "katello_host_collection_hosts" ON "hosts"."id" = "katello_host_collection_hosts"."host_id" WHERE "hosts"."type" = $1 AND "katello_host_collection_hosts"."host_collection_id" = $2 [["type", "Host::Managed"], ["host_collection_id", 202]]
      ..
      2023-11-10T17:29:13 [D|sql|c972f5f9] Host::Managed Load (13.4ms) SELECT "hosts".* FROM "hosts" INNER JOIN "katello_host_collection_hosts" ON "hosts"."id" = "katello_host_collection_hosts"."host_id" WHERE "hosts"."type" = $1 AND "katello_host_collection_hosts"."host_collection_id" = $2 [["type", "Host::Managed"], ["host_collection_id", 300]]
      2023-11-10T17:29:13 [D|sql|c972f5f9] FactValue Load (0.9ms) SELECT "fact_values".* FROM "fact_values" WHERE "fact_values"."host_id" = $1 [["host_id", 2520]]
      ..
      2023-11-10T17:29:13 [I|app|c972f5f9] Completed 200 OK in 25707ms (Views: 23842.3ms | ActiveRecord: 1751.7ms | Allocations: 7109377)

      The queries (for each Host Collection the Host belongs to) "give me all (managed) Hosts from the Host Collection" are the culprit; why do we need them at all..?

              iballou@redhat.com Ian Ballou
              rhn-support-pmoravec Pavel Moravec
              Vladimír Sedmík Vladimír Sedmík
              Votes:
              0 Vote for this issue
              Watchers:
              3 Start watching this issue

                Created:
                Updated:
                Resolved: