-
Bug
-
Resolution: Done
-
Major
-
Pipelines 1.20.0
-
False
-
-
False
-
-
Description of problem:
After approving from group1 as user, group2/user cannot approve because non approver user4 not found
Prerequisites (if any, like setup, operators/versions):
MAG 0.7.0
Steps to Reproduce
1. Create 4 users
2. add user1 and user2 to group1
3. add user3 to group2
4. create approval task and approve as user2. (Should succeed)
5. now login as user3 and try to approve (failing)
Actual results:
Error: failed to approve approvalTask from namespace test: Approver: user4, is not present in the approvers list
Expected results:
ApprovalTask deployment-pipeline-run-z4c9l-approval-gate is approved in test namespace
Reproducibility (Always/Intermittent/Only Once):
Always
Additional info (Such as Logs, Screenshots, etc):
Approvaltask approvers list:
params: - name: approvers value: - user - user1 - group:approver-group #(user1, user2) - group:approver-group2 #(user3)
📦 Name: deployment-pipeline-run-cz9xh-approval-gate 🗂 Namespace: test 🏷️ PipelineRunRef: deployment-pipeline-run-cz9xh 👥 Approvers * user * user1 * approver-group (Group) * approver-group2 (Group) 👨💻 ApproverResponseName ApproverResponse Message approver-group: user2 ✅ ---🌡️ StatusNumberOfApprovalsRequired PendingApprovals STATUS 2 1 Pending
- apiVersion: openshift-pipelines.org/v1alpha1 kind: ApprovalTask metadata: annotations: tekton.dev/last-applied-hash: fae4396a4a28deaa21efdebd6b60ce5ef23795b8fd3e9bccfc56bd668c62da3c creationTimestamp: "2025-08-01T07:41:40Z" generation: 2 labels: tekton.dev/customRun: deployment-pipeline-run-ps65x-approval-gate tekton.dev/memberOf: tasks tekton.dev/pipeline: deployment-pipeline tekton.dev/pipelineRun: deployment-pipeline-run-ps65x tekton.dev/pipelineRunUID: c72c9cd2-535e-4a3c-bea3-edb687db326f tekton.dev/pipelineTask: approval-gate name: deployment-pipeline-run-ps65x-approval-gate namespace: test ownerReferences: - apiVersion: tekton.dev/v1beta1 blockOwnerDeletion: true controller: true kind: CustomRun name: deployment-pipeline-run-ps65x-approval-gate uid: bb82f1ad-a69e-467c-a905-719f77a0355f resourceVersion: "436694" uid: 1a44b262-c317-4287-8fb7-b008b53ae411 spec: approvers: - input: pending name: user type: User - input: pending name: user1 type: User - input: approve name: approver-group type: Group users: - input: approve name: user2 - input: pending name: approver-group2 type: Group description: Approve deployment to production numberOfApprovalsRequired: 2 status: approvalsReceived: 1 approvalsRequired: 2 approvers: - user - user1 - approver-group - approver-group2 approversResponse: - groupMembers: - name: user2 response: approved name: approver-group response: approved type: Group startTime: "2025-08-01T07:41:40Z" state: pending kind: List metadata: resourceVersion: ""
*
When retried again noticed only the approvergroup user2 only can approve all other users are getting this user4 not found in approver list error
