Loading...

Type: Bug
Resolution: Done
Priority: Normal
Fix Version/s: rhos-18.0.0
Affects Version/s: rhos-18.0.0
Component/s: python-openstackclient
Labels:
- Triaged

Story Points:
1
Blocked:
False
Ready:
False
Dev Approval:
Committed
Fixed in Build:
python-openstackclient-6.2.0-0.20230428105153.05d34ff.el9ost
PM Approval:
Committed
QE Approval:
Committed
Regression:
None
Release Note Text:
undefined

Severity:
Moderate

SFDC Cases Counter:
SFDC Cases Open:
SFDC Cases Links:

+++ This bug was initially created as a clone of Bug #1778318 +++

Description of problem:
openstack CLI doesn't show ForcedDown column even with --long when nova client does:

(undercloud) [stack@undercloud-0-rhosp13 cloud]$ nova service-list
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Id

Binary

Host

Zone

Status

State

Updated_at

Disabled Reason

Forced down

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

dca6499e-5c45-412d-af67-a1088b8e154a	nova-conductor	undercloud-0-rhosp13.localdomain	internal	enabled	down	2019-10-23T17:49:38.000000	False
b39ddafe-daa8-443e-b544-194812f2b69c	nova-scheduler	undercloud-0-rhosp13.localdomain	internal	enabled	down	2019-10-23T17:49:41.000000	False
8c9b9ead-2cee-4d4d-87b2-b1a6b95f625f	nova-compute	undercloud-0-rhosp13.localdomain	nova	enabled	down	2019-10-23T18:32:00.000000	False
cc51f140-b628-4894-ae4c-c022116f1bc9	nova-conductor	undercloud-0-rhosp13	internal	enabled	up	2019-11-29T21:58:06.000000	False
8db20d23-c741-4e34-a86f-dcdd28284bd6	nova-scheduler	undercloud-0-rhosp13	internal	enabled	up	2019-11-29T21:58:05.000000	False
5adce325-dd55-4029-8319-8f1f8d46f671	nova-compute	undercloud-0-rhosp13	nova	enabled	up	2019-11-29T21:58:06.000000	False

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(undercloud) [stack@undercloud-0-rhosp13 cloud]$ nova service-force-down 5adce325-dd55-4029-8319-8f1f8d46f671
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------+

ID

Host

Binary

Forced down

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------+

5adce325-dd55-4029-8319-8f1f8d46f671

undercloud-0-rhosp13

nova-compute

True

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
(undercloud) [stack@undercloud-0-rhosp13 cloud]$ openstack compute service list --long
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+

ID

Binary

Host

Zone

Status

State

Updated At

Disabled Reason

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+

1	nova-conductor	undercloud-0-rhosp13.localdomain	internal	enabled	down	2019-10-23T17:49:38.000000	None
2	nova-scheduler	undercloud-0-rhosp13.localdomain	internal	enabled	down	2019-10-23T17:49:41.000000	None
6	nova-compute	undercloud-0-rhosp13.localdomain	nova	enabled	down	2019-10-23T18:32:00.000000	None
8	nova-conductor	undercloud-0-rhosp13	internal	enabled	up	2019-11-29T21:58:36.000000	None
9	nova-scheduler	undercloud-0-rhosp13	internal	enabled	up	2019-11-29T21:58:35.000000	None
11	nova-compute	undercloud-0-rhosp13	nova	enabled	down	2019-11-29T21:58:36.000000	None

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
(undercloud) [stack@undercloud-0-rhosp13 cloud]$ nova service-list
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Id

Binary

Host

Zone

Status

State

Updated_at

Disabled Reason

Forced down

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

dca6499e-5c45-412d-af67-a1088b8e154a	nova-conductor	undercloud-0-rhosp13.localdomain	internal	enabled	down	2019-10-23T17:49:38.000000	False
b39ddafe-daa8-443e-b544-194812f2b69c	nova-scheduler	undercloud-0-rhosp13.localdomain	internal	enabled	down	2019-10-23T17:49:41.000000	False
8c9b9ead-2cee-4d4d-87b2-b1a6b95f625f	nova-compute	undercloud-0-rhosp13.localdomain	nova	enabled	down	2019-10-23T18:32:00.000000	False
cc51f140-b628-4894-ae4c-c022116f1bc9	nova-conductor	undercloud-0-rhosp13	internal	enabled	up	2019-11-29T21:59:56.000000	False
8db20d23-c741-4e34-a86f-dcdd28284bd6	nova-scheduler	undercloud-0-rhosp13	internal	enabled	up	2019-11-29T21:59:55.000000	False
5adce325-dd55-4029-8319-8f1f8d46f671	nova-compute	undercloud-0-rhosp13	nova	enabled	down	2019-11-29T21:59:56.000000	True

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Version-Release number of selected component (if applicable):
Latest

How reproducible:
Always

Steps to Reproduce:
1. Just use both CLI and see
2.
3.

Actual results:
ForcedDown is missing

Expected results:
Maybe we should see it

Additional info:
Just spent 2 days on a case where it was forced down, customer used "openstack compute service list" but I didn't change my habits yet and am still using the "nova" CLI ... this kind of saved the day.

— Additional comment from melanie witt on 2019-12-06 06:43:50 UTC —

Confirmed to be one of the [many] gaps in the compute API microversions support in python-openstackclient [1]. I've added a note to the section for microversion 2.11 on the upstream etherpad [2].

The 'forced_down' field was added to the GET /os-services API in microversion 2.11 [3].

I think adding this would be a simple RFE (open a storyboard story and implement) upstream [4].

We'll discuss this during our bug triage call tomorrow.

[1] https://github.com/openstack/python-openstackclient/blob/5b3a827a1ff80e4b51c7ede44b84bf640d5b6380/openstackclient/compute/v2/service.py#L95
[2] https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/compute-api-microversion-gap-in-osc
[3] https://docs.openstack.org/api-ref/compute/?expanded=list-compute-services-detail#list-compute-services
[4] https://storyboard.openstack.org/#!/project/openstack/python-openstackclient