The XAResourceSetup class (part of Gandiva) createVoid method returns an instance of ExtendedResourceRecord instead of an XAResourceRecord. I haven't tested this hyopthesis yet, but I suspect that we fail silently during transaction initiated recovery and then succeed when recovery is driven from the participant. Thus the workaround for this is to do nothing, as the impact is "only" a delay on recovery. But I need to double check that hypothesis.