Uploaded image for project: 'Infinispan'
  1. Infinispan
  2. ISPN-350

Improve evenness of distribution

    XMLWordPrintable

Details

    • Enhancement
    • Resolution: Done
    • Major
    • 4.1.0.BETA2, 4.1.0.Final
    • 4.0.0.Final, 4.1.0.BETA1
    • Core
    • None
    • High

    Description

      On this 8-node run, compare the stats measured on each node when using Infinispan:

      2010-02-12 07:03:59,123 [main] INFO [org.cachebench.stages.WebSessionBenchmarkStage] On slave 4 we had 9,739 requests per second
      2010-02-12 07:03:59,123 [main] INFO [org.cachebench.stages.WebSessionBenchmarkStage] On slave 7 we had 3,634 requests per second
      2010-02-12 07:03:59,123 [main] INFO [org.cachebench.stages.WebSessionBenchmarkStage] On slave 1 we had 2,966 requests per second
      2010-02-12 07:03:59,123 [main] INFO [org.cachebench.stages.WebSessionBenchmarkStage] On slave 3 we had 2,935 requests per second
      2010-02-12 07:03:59,124 [main] INFO [org.cachebench.stages.WebSessionBenchmarkStage] On slave 2 we had 2,930 requests per second
      2010-02-12 07:03:59,124 [main] INFO [org.cachebench.stages.WebSessionBenchmarkStage] On slave 5 we had 2,925 requests per second
      2010-02-12 07:03:59,124 [main] INFO [org.cachebench.stages.WebSessionBenchmarkStage] On slave 6 we had 2,922 requests per second
      2010-02-12 07:03:59,124 [main] INFO [org.cachebench.stages.WebSessionBenchmarkStage] On slave 0 we had 2,910 requests per second

      against <a popular proprietary product>:

      2010-02-12 06:43:44,747 [main] INFO [org.cachebench.stages.WebSessionBenchmarkStage] On slave 1 we had 12,188 requests per second
      2010-02-12 06:43:44,748 [main] INFO [org.cachebench.stages.WebSessionBenchmarkStage] On slave 7 we had 12,001 requests per second
      2010-02-12 06:43:44,748 [main] INFO [org.cachebench.stages.WebSessionBenchmarkStage] On slave 0 we had 11,978 requests per second
      2010-02-12 06:43:44,748 [main] INFO [org.cachebench.stages.WebSessionBenchmarkStage] On slave 5 we had 11,967 requests per second
      2010-02-12 06:43:44,748 [main] INFO [org.cachebench.stages.WebSessionBenchmarkStage] On slave 3 we had 11,994 requests per second
      2010-02-12 06:43:44,749 [main] INFO [org.cachebench.stages.WebSessionBenchmarkStage] On slave 6 we had 11,961 requests per second
      2010-02-12 06:43:44,749 [main] INFO [org.cachebench.stages.WebSessionBenchmarkStage] On slave 4 we had 11,983 requests per second
      2010-02-12 06:43:44,749 [main] INFO [org.cachebench.stages.WebSessionBenchmarkStage] On slave 2 we had 11,814 requests per second

      This is due to the fact that keys are inequally distributed and some nodes have to deal with greater load than others.

      We need to revisit the bit spreaders we use as well as the way we place nodes on a hash wheel and try and improve on this. Virtual nodes may help as well, although that adds significant complexity to the distribution implementation.

      Attachments

        Issue Links

          Activity

            People

              manik_jira Manik Surtani (Inactive)
              manik_jira Manik Surtani (Inactive)
              Votes:
              0 Vote for this issue
              Watchers:
              0 Start watching this issue

              Dates

                Created:
                Updated:
                Resolved: