-
Bug
-
Resolution: Done
-
Undefined
-
MCE 2.3.0
-
None
Description of problem:
When we disable the hypershift-addon feature, the hypershift-addon does not get updated to reflect this by showing "Disabled" or by removing the Hypershift add-on.
It is only after the hypershift feature is enabled again does the queued up "disabling" happens, which then destroys the ManagedClusterAddon for hypershift.
This is confusing for the user - if I disable it, the addon remains and stays in Available state, but if I re-enable it, I no longer would want it removed ... but that's when it happens.
In 2.8 we plan to GA this feature and therefore it will be enabled by default , but even so if the user were to manually try disabling it they would run into this issue.
At the very least, we should doc this behaviour. Currently our doc does not cover it, it only says this is how to disable the feature after removing hosted clusters:
Version-Release number of selected component (if applicable):
2.8.0-DOWNSTREAM-2023-03-03-17-00-20
How reproducible:
always
Steps to Reproduce:
- enable the hypershift feature by doing
oc patch mce multiclusterengine -n multiclusterngine --type=json -p='[{"op": "add", "path": "/spec/overrides/components/-","value":{"name":"hypershift-preview","enabled":true}}]'
- notice hypershift-addon appears and comes up ready
$ oc get managedclusteraddon -n local-cluster; oc get pods -n hypershift NAME AVAILABLE DEGRADED PROGRESSING application-manager True cert-policy-controller True cluster-proxy True config-policy-controller True governance-policy-framework True hypershift-addon True False iam-policy-controller True work-manager True NAME READY STATUS RESTARTS AGE operator-565d5868d5-scfdh 1/1 Running 0 2m7s operator-77cbdc6469-r595f 1/1 Running 0 2m1s
- disable the hypershift feature by doing
oc patch mce multiclusterengine -n multiclusterngine --type=json -p='[{"op": "add", "path": "/spec/overrides/components/-","value":{"name":"hypershift-preview","enabled":false}}]'
- Observe that the hypershift-addon managedcluster add-on remains showing Available, though the feature is actually Disabled.
$ oc get managedclusteraddon -n local-cluster; oc get pods -n hypershift NAME AVAILABLE DEGRADED PROGRESSING application-manager True cert-policy-controller True cluster-proxy True config-policy-controller True governance-policy-framework True hypershift-addon True False iam-policy-controller True work-manager True NAME READY STATUS RESTARTS AGE operator-77cbdc6469-4pcqd 1/1 Running 0 107s operator-77cbdc6469-r595f 1/1 Running 0 2m48
- Now re-enable the hypershift feature by once again
- Observe this will remove the hypershift-addon and the operator in the ns
oc get managedclusteraddon -n local-cluster; oc get pods -n hypershift NAME AVAILABLE DEGRADED PROGRESSING application-manager True cert-policy-controller True cluster-proxy True config-policy-controller True governance-policy-framework True iam-policy-controller True work-manager True No resources found in hypershift namespace.
Actual results:
- Disabling hypershift doesn't remove addon
- re-enabling hypershift addon after disabling will kill the addon and operator pods
Expected results:
Disabling hypershift will remove the add-on and re-enabling will not remove it
Additional info:
- is cloned by
-
ACM-4052 Disabling hypershift-addon does not removed ManagedClusterAddOn until enabled again
- Closed