Uploaded image for project: 'WildFly Core'
  1. WildFly Core
  2. WFCORE-1485

":read-resource(recursive=true)" generates output with random order, could be ordered alphabetically by keys

    XMLWordPrintable

Details

    Description

      ":read-resource(recursive=true)" generates output with random order, could it be ordered alphabetically by keys

      Now I can't do simple diff of changes, it's necessary to parse output to get valid list of changes.

      I expect output is stored in some structure data format before processed/printed out, could you use some sorted structure (Tree* stuff) ?

      Command to generate output and diff

      jboss-eap-7.0/bin/jboss-cli.sh -c ":read-resource(recursive=true)" > 01 && jboss-eap-7.0/bin/jboss-cli.sh -c ":read-resource(recursive=true)" > 02 
diff 01 02 ## meld kdiff3 or your diff favorite tool

      Diff in my case:

      Unable to find source-code formatter for language: diff. Available languages are: actionscript, ada, applescript, bash, c, c#, c++, cpp, css, erlang, go, groovy, haskell, html, java, javascript, js, json, lua, none, nyan, objc, perl, php, python, r, rainbow, ruby, scala, sh, sql, swift, visualbasic, xml, yaml
      > 02 && diff 01 02
50c50,67
<                                 "security" => {"classification" => {"security-domain" => {
---
>                                 "logging" => {"classification" => {
>                                     "logger" => {
>                                         "configured-application" => undefined,
>                                         "default-application" => false,
>                                         "applies-to" => undefined
>                                     },
>                                     "logging-profile" => {
>                                         "configured-application" => undefined,
>                                         "default-application" => false,
>                                         "applies-to" => undefined
>                                     }
>                                 }},
>                                 "naming" => {"classification" => {"binding" => {
>                                     "configured-application" => undefined,
>                                     "default-application" => false,
>                                     "applies-to" => undefined
>                                 }}},
>                                 "mail" => {"classification" => {"mail-session" => {
64a82,86
>                                 "security" => {"classification" => {"security-domain" => {
>                                     "configured-application" => undefined,
>                                     "default-application" => false,
>                                     "applies-to" => undefined
>                                 }}},
66,70d87
<                                     "data-source" => {
<                                         "configured-application" => undefined,
<                                         "default-application" => false,
<                                         "applies-to" => undefined
<                                     },
80,86d96
<                                     }
<                                 }},
<                                 "logging" => {"classification" => {
<                                     "logging-profile" => {
<                                         "configured-application" => undefined,
<                                         "default-application" => false,
<                                         "applies-to" => undefined
88c98
<                                     "logger" => {
---
>                                     "data-source" => {
93,103c103
<                                 }},
<                                 "mail" => {"classification" => {"mail-session" => {
<                                     "configured-application" => undefined,
<                                     "default-application" => false,
<                                     "applies-to" => undefined
<                                 }}},
<                                 "naming" => {"classification" => {"binding" => {
<                                     "configured-application" => undefined,
<                                     "default-application" => false,
<                                     "applies-to" => undefined
<                                 }}}
---
>                                 }}
106,114d105
<                                 "mail" => {"classification" => {"mail-server-security" => {
<                                     "configured-requires-addressable" => undefined,
<                                     "configured-requires-read" => undefined,
<                                     "configured-requires-write" => undefined,
<                                     "default-requires-addressable" => false,
<                                     "default-requires-read" => false,
<                                     "default-requires-write" => true,
<                                     "applies-to" => undefined
<                                 }}},
116c107
<                                     "naming-binding" => {
---
>                                     "jndi-view" => {
121,122c112,113
<                                         "default-requires-read" => false,
<                                         "default-requires-write" => false,
---
>                                         "default-requires-read" => true,
>                                         "default-requires-write" => true,
125c116
<                                     "jndi-view" => {
---
>                                     "naming-binding" => {
130,131c121,122
<                                         "default-requires-read" => true,
<                                         "default-requires-write" => true,
---
>                                         "default-requires-read" => false,
>                                         "default-requires-write" => false,
153,162c144
<                                 "remoting" => {"classification" => {"remoting-security" => {
<                                     "configured-requires-addressable" => undefined,
<                                     "configured-requires-read" => undefined,
<                                     "configured-requires-write" => undefined,
<                                     "default-requires-addressable" => false,
<                                     "default-requires-read" => true,
<                                     "default-requires-write" => true,
<                                     "applies-to" => undefined
<                                 }}},
<                                 "security" => {"classification" => {"misc-security" => {
---
>                                 "logging" => {"classification" => {"view-server-logs" => {
167,168c149,150
<                                     "default-requires-read" => true,
<                                     "default-requires-write" => true,
---
>                                     "default-requires-read" => false,
>                                     "default-requires-write" => false,
171,172c153,154
<                                 "undertow" => {"classification" => {
<                                     "undertow-handler" => {
---
>                                 "core" => {"classification" => {
>                                     "security-realm-ref" => {
176,178c158,160
<                                         "default-requires-addressable" => false,
<                                         "default-requires-read" => false,
<                                         "default-requires-write" => false,
---
>                                         "default-requires-addressable" => true,
>                                         "default-requires-read" => true,
>                                         "default-requires-write" => true,
181c163
<                                     "undertow-filter" => {
---
>                                     "server-ssl" => {
185,187c167,169
<                                         "default-requires-addressable" => false,
<                                         "default-requires-read" => false,
<                                         "default-requires-write" => false,
---
>                                         "default-requires-addressable" => true,
>                                         "default-requires-read" => true,
>                                         "default-requires-write" => true,
190c172
<                                     "web-connector" => {
---
>                                     "service-container" => {
196c178
<                                         "default-requires-write" => false,
---
>                                         "default-requires-write" => true,
199c181
<                                     "web-access-log" => {
---
>                                     "extensions" => {
205c187
<                                         "default-requires-write" => false,
---
>                                         "default-requires-write" => true,
207,237c189,190
<                                     }
<                                 }},
<                                 "logging" => {"classification" => {"view-server-logs" => {
<                                     "configured-requires-addressable" => undefined,
<                                     "configured-requires-read" => undefined,
<                                     "configured-requires-write" => undefined,
<                                     "default-requires-addressable" => false,
<                                     "default-requires-read" => false,
<                                     "default-requires-write" => false,
<                                     "applies-to" => undefined
<                                 }}},
<                                 "datasources" => {"classification" => {"data-source-security" => {
<                                     "configured-requires-addressable" => undefined,
<                                     "configured-requires-read" => undefined,
<                                     "configured-requires-write" => undefined,
<                                     "default-requires-addressable" => false,
<                                     "default-requires-read" => true,
<                                     "default-requires-write" => true,
<                                     "applies-to" => undefined
<                                 }}},
<                                 "resource-adapters" => {"classification" => {"resource-adapter-security" => {
<                                     "configured-requires-addressable" => undefined,
<                                     "configured-requires-read" => undefined,
<                                     "configured-requires-write" => undefined,
<                                     "default-requires-addressable" => false,
<                                     "default-requires-read" => true,
<                                     "default-requires-write" => true,
<                                     "applies-to" => undefined
<                                 }}},
<                                 "core" => {"classification" => {
<                                     "extensions" => {
---
>                                     },
>                                     "system-property" => {
246c199
<                                     "service-container" => {
---
>                                     "module-loading" => {
255c208
<                                     "domain-controller" => {
---
>                                     "jvm" => {
264c217
<                                     "domain-names" => {
---
>                                     "snapshots" => {
270c223
<                                         "default-requires-write" => true,
---
>                                         "default-requires-write" => false,
273c226
<                                     "security-domain-ref" => {
---
>                                     "access-control" => {
291c244
<                                     "management-interfaces" => {
---
>                                     "credential" => {
296c249
<                                         "default-requires-read" => false,
---
>                                         "default-requires-read" => true,
300c253
<                                     "socket-binding-ref" => {
---
>                                     "management-interfaces" => {
306c259
<                                         "default-requires-write" => false,
---
>                                         "default-requires-write" => true,
309c262
<                                     "socket-config" => {
---
>                                     "security-domain" => {
313,314c266,267
<                                         "default-requires-addressable" => false,
<                                         "default-requires-read" => false,
---
>                                         "default-requires-addressable" => true,
>                                         "default-requires-read" => true,
318c271
<                                     "security-vault" => {
---
>                                     "patching" => {
323c276
<                                         "default-requires-read" => true,
---
>                                         "default-requires-read" => false,
327c280
<                                     "server-ssl" => {
---
>                                     "read-whole-config" => {
331c284
<                                         "default-requires-addressable" => true,
---
>                                         "default-requires-addressable" => false,
336c289
<                                     "jvm" => {
---
>                                     "domain-controller" => {
345c298
<                                     "module-loading" => {
---
>                                     "security-vault" => {
350c303
<                                         "default-requires-read" => false,
---
>                                         "default-requires-read" => true,
354c307
<                                     "security-domain" => {
---
>                                     "security-domain-ref" => {
363c316
<                                     "snapshots" => {
---
>                                     "socket-binding-ref" => {
372c325
<                                     "credential" => {
---
>                                     "domain-names" => {
377c330
<                                         "default-requires-read" => true,
---
>                                         "default-requires-read" => false,
381c334
<                                     "read-whole-config" => {
---
>                                     "socket-config" => {
386c339
<                                         "default-requires-read" => true,
---
>                                         "default-requires-read" => false,
389,390c342,363
<                                     },
<                                     "patching" => {
---
>                                     }
>                                 }},
>                                 "mail" => {"classification" => {"mail-server-security" => {
>                                     "configured-requires-addressable" => undefined,
>                                     "configured-requires-read" => undefined,
>                                     "configured-requires-write" => undefined,
>                                     "default-requires-addressable" => false,
>                                     "default-requires-read" => false,
>                                     "default-requires-write" => true,
>                                     "applies-to" => undefined
>                                 }}},
>                                 "resource-adapters" => {"classification" => {"resource-adapter-security" => {
>                                     "configured-requires-addressable" => undefined,
>                                     "configured-requires-read" => undefined,
>                                     "configured-requires-write" => undefined,
>                                     "default-requires-addressable" => false,
>                                     "default-requires-read" => true,
>                                     "default-requires-write" => true,
>                                     "applies-to" => undefined
>                                 }}},
>                                 "undertow" => {"classification" => {
>                                     "undertow-filter" => {
396c369
<                                         "default-requires-write" => true,
---
>                                         "default-requires-write" => false,
399c372
<                                     "access-control" => {
---
>                                     "web-connector" => {
403,405c376,378
<                                         "default-requires-addressable" => true,
<                                         "default-requires-read" => true,
<                                         "default-requires-write" => true,
---
>                                         "default-requires-addressable" => false,
>                                         "default-requires-read" => false,
>                                         "default-requires-write" => false,
408c381
<                                     "system-property" => {
---
>                                     "undertow-handler" => {
414c387
<                                         "default-requires-write" => true,
---
>                                         "default-requires-write" => false,
417c390
<                                     "security-realm-ref" => {
---
>                                     "web-access-log" => {
421,423c394,396
<                                         "default-requires-addressable" => true,
<                                         "default-requires-read" => true,
<                                         "default-requires-write" => true,
---
>                                         "default-requires-addressable" => false,
>                                         "default-requires-read" => false,
>                                         "default-requires-write" => false,
426c399,426
<                                 }}
---
>                                 }},
>                                 "datasources" => {"classification" => {"data-source-security" => {
>                                     "configured-requires-addressable" => undefined,
>                                     "configured-requires-read" => undefined,
>                                     "configured-requires-write" => undefined,
>                                     "default-requires-addressable" => false,
>                                     "default-requires-read" => true,
>                                     "default-requires-write" => true,
>                                     "applies-to" => undefined
>                                 }}},
>                                 "remoting" => {"classification" => {"remoting-security" => {
>                                     "configured-requires-addressable" => undefined,
>                                     "configured-requires-read" => undefined,
>                                     "configured-requires-write" => undefined,
>                                     "default-requires-addressable" => false,
>                                     "default-requires-read" => true,
>                                     "default-requires-write" => true,
>                                     "applies-to" => undefined
>                                 }}},
>                                 "security" => {"classification" => {"misc-security" => {
>                                     "configured-requires-addressable" => undefined,
>                                     "configured-requires-read" => undefined,
>                                     "configured-requires-write" => undefined,
>                                     "default-requires-addressable" => false,
>                                     "default-requires-read" => true,
>                                     "default-requires-write" => true,
>                                     "applies-to" => undefined
>                                 }}}

      Attachments

        Issue Links

          clones

          Bug - A problem that impairs or prevents the functions of the product. JBEAP-4262 ":read-resource(recursive=true)" generates output with random order, could be ordered alphabetically by keys

          • Major - To be worked after higher priority work items are addressed. When the severity is high and the effort to change it is low to moderate, this term is chosen. Issues in this category likely have an existing workaround but implementation or execution may be non-trivial.
          • Verified

          Activity

            People

              lthon@redhat.com Ladislav Thon
              lthon@redhat.com Ladislav Thon
              Votes:
              0 Vote for this issue
              Watchers:
              3 Start watching this issue

              Dates

                Created:
                Updated:
                Resolved: